In the property division phase of divorce in Texas, one of the most difficult items to divide is a
pension or retirement account. Part of this difficulty stems from the challenges associated with
valuation: pensions often have a portion which is not yet “vested,” and employers also frequently
provide “matching” after the given employee retires. Furthermore, certain retirement accounts do
not consist of fully liquid assets but involve investments in funds which are not fully liquid. Even
though dividing pensions and retirement accounts can be quite difficult, Texas courts still divide
these things very often because these accounts are considered part of the community estate like
any other asset.
In the case of Key v. Key (2025), a husband appealed a divorce judgment which “undervalued”
the wife’s pension by a sizable amount. In appealing, the husband hoped to challenge this low
valuation and derive a greater amount in the judgment. Let us look at this important case more
carefully.
Facts of the Case
The couple in this case divorced after nearly three decades of marriage. When the spouses
divorced, the wife had a pension initially approximately valued at $400,000 by the trial court.
Collectively, the spouses’ combined community estate was worth about $1.8 million. The
husband argued that the court had failed to take into account evidence which would have
supported a much greater valuation of the wife’s pension. The husband’s expert, for instance, put
a value on the wife’s pension at nearly $2.4 million in 2022; the wife also had her own expert
who provided information on valuation, and his estimate was considerably lower. Neither of the
experts testified at trial; however, both provided reports which contained various pieces of
evidence.
The trial court divided the community estate in a slightly uneven manner, with the wife being
awarded $920,000, and the husband awarded about $888,000. The husband appealed the
judgment, contending that the court erred by not attaching a much higher valuation to the wife’s
pension.
Outcome and Discussion
After reviewing the case, the appellate court pointed out that pension rights are considered a
“contingent property interest,” meaning that their full value includes the pension’s worth before
it fully matures. In its decision, the court highlighted that the wife’s expert said the valuation was
a “discounted present value,” which meant it did not necessarily account for future payments.
The expert’s valuation also did not include the matching contributions from the wife’s former
employer, which were apparently more than half the total value of the community estate.
The appellate court also mentioned some of the common challenges that come with valuing and
dividing pensions – challenges we pointed out earlier. Because the wife’s expert had overlooked
some key evidence and the valuation from the husband’s expert was not given enough weight,
the appellate division decided to overturn the part of the divorce judgment that dealt with the
pension division. The case was sent back to the trial court to focus specifically on how the
pension should be valued and divided.
Contact Goldsberry Portz Divorce & Family Lawyers, PLLC, for More Resources
If readers would like additional information on pension valuation in divorce, the general division
of retirement accounts, or another family law topic, contact one of the experienced and reputable
family law lawyers at Goldsberry Portz Divorce & Family Lawyers, PLLC, today by calling 281-
485-3500.