In Texas, grandparents do not have special rights when it comes to their grandchildren. A lot of people believe they do, but that is not the case. The law treats grandparents the same as anyone else who is not a parent. They do not get any special treatment or advantages. This might surprise some people, but it is how the law works in Texas. While courts might sometimes be more open to grandparents, they still do not have automatic rights.
For a grandparent to get legal custody or conservatorship, they need to ask the court or be recommended by an agency like the Texas Department of Family & Protective Services (DFPS). Even then, the court’s decision is based on what is best for the child. It is not about the relationship between the grandparent and the child. Because of this, it is not easy for a grandparent to win. In the case of M.B. & C.J. v. Texas DFPS (2024), a grandmother was able to get conservatorship. But, this is rare. Let us take a closer look at what happened in this case.
Facts of the Case
The mother and father in this case had two children, born in 2015 and 2016. Both children had developmental disabilities, including autism, and were placed in special needs educational programs. The parents had a history of relationship problems. Specifically, the mother had a history of domestic violence, repeatedly getting into violent conflicts with the father. She also had a lengthy criminal record with various offenses.
In 2021, because of the mother’s behavior, the court granted primary conservatorship to the father. The mother was only given limited visitation rights. Then, in 2023, things changed. The court discovered that the father was physically abusing the children. Because of this, the father’s conservatorship was changed, and primary conservatorship was temporarily given to the Texas DFPS.
Before the DFPS got involved, the children had been living with their grandmother. The DFPS supported giving the grandmother sole conservatorship. The court agreed and granted her conservatorship. The parents were given very limited visitation rights—just one supervised visit per month each. The parents appealed the decision, and the case went to the appellate court for review.
Outcome and Discussion
The appellate court reviewed the case and decided to rule in favor of the grandmother. The court determined that granting her sole conservatorship was in the best interests of the children. In making this decision, the court looked at several key factors: (1) the long history of family violence between the mother and father, (2) the father’s recent physical abuse and neglect of the children, (3) the grandmother’s established relationship with the children, (4) the better living conditions the grandmother could provide, and (5) the recommendation of the Texas DFPS.
The court also considered various pieces of evidence, including testimony from the mother’s fiancé, her therapist, and a DFPS caseworker. After reviewing everything, the court concluded that the grandmother was the best option for the children’s care.
What makes this case so rare is the extreme circumstances. There was a lot of domestic violence, instability, and physical abuse toward the children. These serious issues were enough for the court to take away conservatorship from both parents.
Contact Goldsberry Portz Divorce & Family Lawyers, PLLC, for More Resources
If readers want more information on parental rights in Texas, conservatorship issues in general,
or another related family law topic, contact one of the family law attorneys at Goldsberry Portz
Divorce & Family Lawyers, PLLC, today by calling 281-485-3500.